It has been a tough year for poets. Two months ago Laura Bush cancelled a White House poetry symposium honoring Emily Dickinson, Langston Hughes and Walt Whitman. The First Lady feared the invited poets may invoke poems critical of invading Iraq. [includes rush transcript]
A spokesperson for Bush explained the cancellation at the time by saying: "While Mrs. Bush respects and believes in the right of all Americans to express their opinions, she too has opinions and believes that it would be inappropriate to turn what is intended to be a literary event into a political forum."
Across the country thousands of poets protested the decision and countless poetry readings were held from coast to coast.
In Vermont, the 80-year-old Grace Paley took part in one of these readings alongside Jamaica Kincaid, Galway Kinnell and other well known poets. According to a local press account only Paley received a standing ovation. One of her poems dated from the 1960s and compared the mountains of Vermont to those of Vietnam. It included the line: "The holes in the mountains are red."
Paley has been active in the peace and poetry movements since the 1960s. Living in New York she helped found the Greenwich Village Peace Center in 1961. Eight years later she went on a peace mission to Hanoi during the war. She attended the World Peace Conference in 1974. She would go on to actively take part in the antinuclear and women’s peace movements. In 1980, she helped organize the Women’s Pentagon Action. And in 1985 Paley visited Nicaragua and El Salvador, after having campaigned against the U.S. government’s policies toward these countries. She was also one of "The White House Eleven," who were arrested in 1978 for unfurling an anti-nuclear banner on the White House lawn.
On the literary front, she is one of the nation’s most acclaimed writers. She has received countless awards and glowing reviews for her poetry and fiction. Among her books are ??The Little Disturbances of Man, ??Later the Same Day, ??Enormous Changes at the Last Minute. She has received, among other prizes, a Lannan Literary Award, a National Book Award, a Guggenheim Fellowship, and an award from the National Institute of Arts and Letters. She also is the recipient of several awards from the National Endowment for the Arts (including a Senior Fellowship in recognition of her lifetime contribution to literature).
And last week for the second time she became an official state poet. First she was the official state poet of New York from 1986 to 1988 and now she has been selected as Vermont’s official state poet.
- Grace Paley, poet, writer and activist.
This is a rush transcript. Copy may not be in its final form.
AMY GOODMAN: She joins us in the studio today. Welcome to Democracy Now!
GRACE PALEY: Thank you.
AMY GOODMAN: It’s great to have you with us, Grace. I watched you last night at an event where the readings of women around war took place. Women on War is the name of a new book that includes your writings. But I’d like to start off by you talking about your response to Laura Bush’s poetry symposium and then canceling it, and what happened with you and sister and fellow poets around the country.
GRACE PALEY: Yeah. Well, it was probably the most extraordinary event to happen to American poets, and Laura Bush did it. It couldn’t have happened, though, really, without — you know, when people say, "What can poets do?" I often say, "Just what any other working group could do to get anything accomplished, and that is to organize." You know, one poet is a nice thing, saying no. And, you know, it gets the papers, sounds good.
But then Sam Hamill came along from Copper Canyon Press, and that’s where things began to happen. So I owe — we — all poets owe a great deal to Laura Bush, Sam Hamill and the computer, because, as this happened, within about two days, there were about — I don’t know — 15,000 poets writing letters, writing, sending poems to Laura Bush, poems of protest. But more than that, they were beginning to do readings, which were attended by — you know, if you’re a poet, you can sometimes read to seven people and you’re happy, but these readings had packed houses. It was really quite an extraordinary experience for almost any poet. And this was true not only in Vermont, but, from what I hear, all over the country. So it was great.
I just want to say one thing. It brought me back to olden times. You know, by that I mean like twenty or thirty years ago. For us to organize a thing like this, which we did do during the Vietnam War, something called "Angry Arts," which we worked at, took us months, took us really a long time. By the time we got the mail out and by the time we got all the volunteers to come in and lick the envelopes and by the time all that was done, it was a long — and this happened like that in three days. So it was quite extraordinary, you know?
AMY GOODMAN: Well, you were recently named the poet laureate of Vermont. It’s very interesting. You’re named by the governor, who is a Republican governor. Can you talk about how you relate to him in your meeting with him?
GRACE PALEY: Well, first of all, he really — he didn’t — well, he had to sign the paper, but I was chosen by a group of other poets, a couple of whom had been laureates, like Galway Kinnell and Ellen Voigt, and a couple of other people who had to make a choice. I don’t even think I was the best one, but that’s beside the point. Still, there — you know, there’s time for others. And then I had to meet with him. He wanted to meet with me and talk to me, but before he really signed on. And I — he knew a lot about me, and I said, well, I wasn’t going to change very much, you know? I’d probably be the same person I was, no matter what. And we talked awhile about this fact. And he really — and then he signed it. That’s all.
AMY GOODMAN: Governor James Douglas?
GRACE PALEY: Yes. He’s a Republican. He has a very mild manner, and I don’t know whether that’s the part of the Republicans of Vermont or what, but he’s a Republican. I mean, there’s no question about it.
AMY GOODMAN: But in terms of your poetry, more significantly, here he is naming you poet laureate, whether he chose you or not —
GRACE PALEY: Right.
AMY GOODMAN: — he is for the war, and you’re opposed.
GRACE PALEY: Yeah, right. Yeah.
AMY GOODMAN: And you have been using your poetry a lot in the last few months to express that view.
GRACE PALEY: Well, I would do that, no matter what. I mean, this is what I’m about, and this is how I live my life. It’s — I don’t even — I wouldn’t understand how to do otherwise.
AMY GOODMAN: What about the position of state poet laureates?
GRACE PALEY: Well, you don’t have to do anything. It’s an honorific, really. And if I chose to just sit around and write poems, which would be nice, I could do that, you know? But very few others have done that. And people have, before me, have done a lot of good work.
But what I — what happened to me in this first month is that I’ve gotten so many requests to read at this library in Rutland, that place in Brattleboro, and all over the state, and I’m very ill-equipped by my organizational gifts or the state of my desk to really get everything straight about where I should be. The last place I was was at a Barre senior center reading to and talking with a lot of old people, a lot of old people, many of whom were younger than me. And — but they loved poetry. They really loved poetry, and they wanted to hear me read poems. They wanted to tell me about their poems. It’s really great, you know?
AMY GOODMAN: Grace Paley, can you talk about your background? Can you talk about your family, coming from Russia when they came, what their politics were?
GRACE PALEY: Well, I’m from the Bronx originally. And my parents came over here in 1905 from Russia from a town called Yuzovka. And they were — my father had been in prison before that, and my mother was in exile for a while. And then the czar had a son, and when he had a son, all the people under twenty-one were pardoned. And so, my grandmother got them all out of Russia, and they came to the United States. So that was their politics. They were social democrats, actually. And they didn’t do much political stuff. Once they got here, they just worked like hell. And my father, supported by the women in the family, aunts and so forth and mother, went to school and became a doctor very soon and moved to the Bronx. And that was my life.
AMY GOODMAN: When did you discover the written word, whether it was poetry or prose? When did you start?
GRACE PALEY: Well, I had an older sister. My brother and sister are both fifteen years older than I am, and they were very — my sister, especially, read to me a great deal, and she liked poetry. She happened to like poetry, and she read poems to me. And so, I began to write little poems, you know, cute stuff, you know? You write — by that time, my sister and brother, who were the children of the working class — I came along, and I was a child of the middle class fifteen years later. And so, they — you write a sentence, and everybody says to you, "Oh, isn’t that nice," you know? And so, you write another one. And then I began to be, you know, a big reader, what we used to call in the old days a "big reader."
AMY GOODMAN: When did you — actually, when were you first published?
GRACE PALEY: Well, you see, I wrote poetry for a long time, and I had hardly ever sent anything out. And I think I may have published a couple poems when I was about twenty. And then I had children and led another life, but kept writing and began to write stories in my mid-thirties, and that’s what I published. I did not publish poems until many years later.
AMY GOODMAN: And how did the politics of the times — for example, the Vietnam War — weigh in? The nuclear movement — how did that affect what you were doing and what you saw your role as a writer and poet as?
GRACE PALEY: Well, I never saw my role — I never thought of it like that, you know? I mean, that’s what I was doing. And at the same time, I did have these very strong political feelings and very natural ones, they seemed, to me.
And so, even when my kids were smaller, you had three — people like me had three things to do. They had the family to take care of and to worry about. And they had our political lives to lead — I mean, I should say the business of the war or whatever it was. And then we also had our work, our life work, which for me was literature, which I — which was my great good luck that I had that, because it enabled me to think in another way than a lot of other people.
AMY GOODMAN: Your mother was protesting way back. You talked about the bus.
GRACE PALEY: Well, that was — I wrote a story about that called "Traveling," about my mother, in 1927, going to visit my brother at college — was sitting in the back of the bus as they went down, and when they got to Washington they asked her to please move to the front, and she refused.
But what’s interesting about that, to me, was that my sister never really told me that story until like five years — seven years ago, eight years ago, something like that. She just never told it to me. And when she did tell it to me, it meant a great deal, because I remembered my own trip down south in 1943. And it became a story in this book called Just as I Thought, in which my grandson, who isn’t white, also appears and brought it all together. That’s the thing about writing. You can bring a lot of stuff together.
AMY GOODMAN: Could you read something you have written? Can you read one of your poems?
GRACE PALEY: OK.
AMY GOODMAN: You have your Grace Paley Begin Again: Collected Poems book in front of you. Grace Paley is with us. She is the poet laureate of Vermont, has written many poems and books and was here in New York last night for a reading, for an international anthology of writings from antiquity to the present called Women on War. Grace Paley.
GRACE PALEY: Published by the Feminist Press. OK. This poem is called "Fathers."
these days they have
accomplished this by
being more mothering
what luck for them that
women’s lib happened then
the dream of new fathering
began to shine in the eyes
of free women and was irresistible
on the New York subways
and the mass transits
of other cities one may
see fatherings of many colors
with their round babies on
their laps this may also
happen in the countryside
these scenes were brand-new
exciting for an old woman who
had watched the old fathers
gathering once again in
familiar Army camps and com-
fortable war rooms to consider
the necessary eradication of
the new fathering fathers
(who are their sons) as well
as the women and children who
will surely be in the way.
AMY GOODMAN: Grace Paley, her poem "Fathers." Grace, in your life, you’ve spent time in jail protesting. What has that meant to you, how it has affected your writing?
GRACE PALEY: Well, I haven’t — you know, I guess I — it’s only interesting to me, the time I spent a week, but I’ve never spent real time in jail, just like overnights. A lot of overnights is the way it happened, or two days or three. But one time, by accident, by the accident of a judge, I spent a week, a whole week, in the women’s house of detention. And it, you know, was a teaching experience. It was a very valuable experience to be among all those women. And I wrote about it. And I — it was a funny experience, because I lived right around the corner from the house of —- women’s house of detention -—
GRACE PALEY: Here in New York.
GRACE PALEY: — which was on Tenth Street at the time.
AMY GOODMAN: Where Angela Davis was also.
GRACE PALEY: Yeah. And I used to look out the window, and I could see my kids going to school, you know? And it was a very —- that was very -—
AMY GOODMAN: Did you yell through the bars, "Dress warmly"?
GRACE PALEY: Well, I almost did, you know, but they weren’t paying attention. They just wanted to go their way. But people did yell up to me and yell up and say, "Grace, how are you?" You know.
AMY GOODMAN: Well, maybe that’s why it’s no longer there, right in the middle of civilization in New York.
GRACE PALEY: Well, it’s a terrible thing that it’s not there, because once they moved that prison, they moved it out to Rikers Island. See, when it was there on that street, people could come, and they — older people remember that — and on Sixth Avenue, they would stand there, and they’d yell up to everybody. And people would be able to — apart from visiting, they could see each other out the windows and yell out back and forth, "How’s the kids?" You know?
AMY GOODMAN: Well, on that note, I want to thank you very much for being with us.
GRACE PALEY: OK, thank you.
AMY GOODMAN: Grace Paley, you write about that experience in Just As I Thought. And a new anthology, Women on War, put out by Feminist Press, also has Grace’s writings.