
With Democrats set to take control of both chambers of Congress in January, Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders says he will not support Chuck Schumer for another term as the Democratic Senate leader, calling for the party to move in “a new and bold direction.” Michigan Democratic Senator Elissa Slotkin has said she will not support Schumer unless he presents a plan to govern differently, and several senators-elect have called for new leadership or declined to endorse Schumer. Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen is considering challenging Schumer. Meanwhile, Hakeem Jeffries is facing questions about his leadership of House Democrats after 11 of the party’s members missed a key vote on impeaching Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth.
After “a big win for the populist wing of the Democratic Party, … it would be a betrayal for that election to result immediately in the Democratic Party simply responding by reelecting the same leadership,” says David Sirota, editor-in-chief of The Lever.
Transcript
AMY GOODMAN: This is Democracy Now!, democracynow.org, The War and Peace Report. I’m Amy Goodman, with Nermeen Shaikh.
NERMEEN SHAIKH: As Democrats prepare to take control of the House in January, their current leader, Hakeem Jeffries, is facing questions about his leadership after a vote this week that effectively derailed an effort to impeach Trump’s Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth. On Tuesday, the Republican-led House voted 211 to 204 to send the articles to the House Judiciary Committee, effectively stalling the effort. Eleven Democrats were absent, including former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi. The vote prompted criticism of Jeffries, who is seeking to become House speaker, with some questioning why he had not ensured more Democrats were present.
AMY GOODMAN: The debate over Democratic leadership in the House and Senate is also intensifying in that upper house, in the Senate. Vermont independent Senator Bernie Sanders says he will not support Chuck Schumer for another term as the party’s leader, calling for Democrats to move in, quote, “a new and bold direction.”
SEN. BERNIE SANDERS: If this campaign was about anything, it was about change and the need for the Democratic Party, in my view, to move in a new and bold direction. I personally have known Chuck Schumer for over 30 years, and I like Chuck. Nobody who works harder than Chuck Schumer. But in my view, the time is now for change, and I will not be supporting Chuck to be reelected as the Democratic leader.
AMY GOODMAN: That’s Bernie Sanders. Michigan Democratic Senator Elissa Slotkin has also said she will not support Schumer unless he presents a plan for a different vision. It’s not clear if she would throw her hat in the ring. Several senators-elect have called for new leadership or declined to endorse Schumer. Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen says he’s listening to colleagues and has not ruled out a leadership bid.
The debate over who should lead the Democratic Party comes as the party prepares to take control of Congress following its sweeping midterm victories. The question now is what Democrats will do with that power and whether they’ll deliver on the promises they campaigned on.
The Lever has launched a new video and podcast series hosted by David Sirota called Don’t F#*k It Up, Democrats — but they’re using the full word. Let’s go to a preview.
DAVID SIROTA: After election night, what comes next? I’m David Sirota, founder of The Lever and host of the award-winning investigative podcast Master Plan. Right now Americans are not politely asking for change. They’re mad. So, as the party looks towards the next Congress and the 2028 presidential election, we’re asking: What would it actually take for Democrats to get it right?
ROBERT REICH: How do Democrats not [bleep] this up again?
DAVID SIROTA: And so, our new series has a title that channels that anger and requires a bleep. It’s called Don’t [bleep] It Up, Democrats. I’m sitting down with politicians, economists, activists, former White House officials, power brokers and thinkers to talk about the big choices facing the party. How do you fight corruption when billionaires bankroll the political system? How do you make life affordable when corporations have so much power? How do you fix a healthcare system that’s bankrupting people? And how do Democrats win back working-class voters who’ve heard promises of change again and again? Winning elections is one thing, but actually delivering on your promises, that’s something else.
ROBERT REICH: Because Democrats do have an extraordinary capacity to grab defeat out of the jaws of victory again and again and again and again.
AMY GOODMAN: And that voice, that last voice, was former Labor Secretary Robert Reich.
Well, for more, we go to Lisbon, Portugal, where we’re joined by David Sirota, founder and editor-in-chief of The Lever, the author of the Master Plan: The Hidden Plot to Legalize Corruption in America.
David, that’s quite a provocative title for your podcast series, Don’t F#*k It Up. Can you talk about what’s just taken place? We’re speaking to you the day after the victory of Scott Colom, the first Black senator — he will be — from Mississippi since Reconstruction. And to say the least, in the last few days, he was very critical of the Democrats who refused to fund him, the leadership, until the very end. Talk about what you’re seeing in the House and the Senate now.
DAVID SIROTA: Look, I think what you’re seeing is, clearly, in the vote across the country, a massive vote for change. And let’s be really clear here: Many of the races that decided this election were won by candidates who were making a very crystal-clear critique of the status quo, of oligarchy, of the endemic corruption. Essentially, the way I see it, you see an election in which the politics, the anti-oligarch politics, that have been championed by people like Bernie Sanders, ended up winning the day, and winning the day in a huge way, particularly in places like red states.
And I think what you’re then seeing now reflected in the leadership races is whether that wave will result in some reflection of change. There would be an irony to have an election with a wave this clear, this anti-oligarch, this populist, a wave that was a big win for the populist wing of the Democratic Party, a wave that is about change — it would be more than ironic — some would argue it would be a betrayal — for that election to result immediately in the Democratic Party simply responding by reelecting the same leadership. So, I think you’ve got a lot of Democrats on Capitol Hill who are caught between knowing what the election was about, and also an existing current leadership, Democratic Party leadership, that doesn’t want the leadership of the party to have to change.
NERMEEN SHAIKH: So, David, if we could just, you know, go back and see: Why do so many progressives, progressive Democrats, and their supporters — why don’t they want to support Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer? If you could just give us a history of their — basically, their record?
DAVID SIROTA: Yeah, I mean, for sure. I mean, look, Hakeem Jeffries is somebody who, as an example, most recently, right before the election, said that he is not a supporter of Medicare for All. Hakeem Jeffries has promised to stack the House Foreign Affairs Committee with AIPAC — members who are very close to AIPAC, who are very supportive of the existing relationship, U.S.-Israel relationship. You have a steering committee in the House that’s supposed to be writing the Democrats’ AI policy, and it is comprised of lawmakers who are very close, not surprisingly, to the tech industry.
Chuck Schumer has been somebody who has danced around all sorts of issues. For instance, he ended up not supporting a major antitrust bill. He is not somebody who is perceived to have used the Senate, the power in the Senate, to really deliver on or really champion a populist agenda. And so, I think, look, I think with Schumer, there’s some generational change. I mean, Chuck Schumer has been leader for a very long time, through some very, very bad Democratic losses. So, Schumer’s got a generational question here, you know, a demand for new leadership. Jeffries hasn’t been speaker, but Jeffries is juxtaposing himself policy-wise in many ways against the base and against, in some cases, the majority of his own party.
NERMEEN SHAIKH: So, David, do you have any idea of who the candidates might be to replace Schumer or Jeffries?
DAVID SIROTA: Yeah, I mean, look, Chris Van Hollen, I think, is the most serious challenger, right now, to Chuck Schumer. Chris Van Hollen actually was on The Lever’s podcast just before the election, making a clear line in the sand, saying Democrats should use the upcoming continuing resolution to try to block funding for the Iran war, something that Chuck Schumer has not been willing to do or say. Chris Van Hollen is somebody who has been a serious Iran war critic, a serious critic of war in general, and much closer to the progressive populist base of the Democratic Party than, I think, Chuck Schumer.
Hakeem Jeffries, an official challenger has not emerged yet. There’s been a huge petition, a set of — I think it’s a million signatures at this point — demanding a different leader than Hakeem Jeffries. A single candidate has not happened yet, has not emerged, although there is some talk — there is a push to have it be Ayanna Pressley from Massachusetts.
AMY GOODMAN: I wanted to go to Senator Van Hollen, who publicly criticized the Democratic leader Chuck Schumer and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee for refusing to support the campaigns of Democratic candidates who went on to win, like Dr. Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan and Troy Jackson of Maine.
SEN. CHRIS VAN HOLLEN: We have two members in that room, newly elected senators, who would not be there if Schumer and the DSCC had had their way. And, you know, Schumer and the DSCC sided with the crypto industry and AIPAC against these candidates.
AMY GOODMAN: I mean, this is very interesting. I wanted to get your response to this and to now Mississippi Senator-elect Scott Colom, who was speaking, sharply criticizing national Democrats for writing Mississippi off and failing to invest in his campaign early on. He said, quote, “Mississippi was never a lost cause. We were a betrayed cause.” He was speaking on NBC News before the election.
SCOTT COLOM: The reality is, our country does not do well when it ignores places like Mississippi. When America makes sure kids in Mississippi have good education, that teachers got the pay they need to actually teach the students, where we make sure that hospitals are open and that healthcare is accessible, and that we actually live up to our American values, the country does well. When the country ignores places like Mississippi, inevitably it catches up with the country, and we all suffer. So, we have to understand that the math and the morals in Mississippi have to matter. …
You can’t lead with doubt. You have to believe. You have to lead with belief. And that’s where the power is. When you believe things, you can actually achieve it. And there’s some people in the party that they are just treading water. Right? “What’s the path to least resistance to get to 51? Ooh my gosh, we did it.” That’s not the right way to think. In this particular moment, you have to think about how can we win everywhere, because we need to represent working people in a way where we actually deliver.
AMY GOODMAN: So, there you have Scott Colom speaking right before the election on NBC News. Respond to Van Hollen, what he has said, and Colom.
DAVID SIROTA: Yeah, I think — look, I think what they’re talking about is a Democratic Party that has a broader vision than the current Democratic Party. And I think all of this is pointing to not just how Democrats need to try to win, but also how they need to try to compete to deliver. And that is a — that is the biggest question of all right now. Will a Democratic Party, with margins that it has now, really think more transformatively than it has in the past when it has had such majorities?
And that fight is playing out right now in politics. You see factions of the Democratic Party competing to decide and define what is possible right now. You see one faction saying we should demand votes on Medicare for All, we should demand votes on a much — on a really expansive agenda. Then you see the corporate Democrats trying to say, “No, no, no, no. This was essentially a status quo election. So-called moderates won.”
I tend to agree, in one sense, that Bernie Sanders-style anti-oligarch, populist agenda has become and is now being recognized as a moderate centrist agenda, but you have a faction of corporate-friendly Democrats who are trying to already preemptively slow down a push for Democrats to try to deliver in a big way. There’s this big conference that’s coming up in Denver where a billionaire-funded group is convening Democrats right now. This is the same group that has said that Democrats, for instance, should not push for a Medicare for All vote, should not even try to put a Medicare for All or Medicare for All-style bill on Donald Trump’s desk.
NERMEEN SHAIKH: Well, The Lever has been closely reporting on the gathering. On Thursday, Democracy Now! reached The Lever’s Luke Goldstein.
LUKE GOLDSTEIN: There are two things that are really distinct about the Majority Democrats/Bench political operation. For one, they sort of offer the candidates they work with access to a really illustrious and powerful donor network that they control. There’s a lot of dark money that funds these groups, as well as large donors, primarily from Wall Street and Silicon Valley, you know, tech and finance sectors, for the most part.
And then the other additional service that’s more unique is that these groups offer, essentially, a political-operative-for-rent service to candidates. So, they have a setup of real kind of insider political operatives, probably most prominently Lis Smith, who previously worked on the Pete Buttigieg campaign in 2020. And those candidates will work with different campaigns at the same time as they work with these outside PACs, and it allows these groups to really kind of control and have a centralized narrative and political messaging that you’ll see spread out across those candidates.
I think it’s fair to say that these groups have a more kind of moderate political orientation. They definitely don’t support policies, for example, like Medicare for All. I would say that they are uneasy about policies like a data center moratorium. And they’re fairly hostile to the more left-wing climate and immigration groups, certainly.
NERMEEN SHAIKH: So, that’s The Lever’s Luke Goldstein. And the meeting is happening today. If you could say more, David, about this billionaire-backed group, the Majority Democrats?
DAVID SIROTA: I think it — let’s add some context here. Look, we have seen this is sort of the faction with a thousand faces. People who have watched this show know this faction as the old Democratic Leadership Council. It has become the so-called — the group Third Way. It is the so-called New Democrats. Now it is called Majority Democrats. This is the same faction over and over throughout the generations: corporate-friendly Democrats who believe that winning politics means coddling oligarchs, means incrementalist-at-best policies, means a sort of deal with the corporate class for very small changes. It is essentially the faction that broke the Democratic Party away from its New Deal coalition and its New Deal agenda.
And so, Majority Democrats is a billionaire-backed group that is convening Democrats to negotiate right now at its conference, try to negotiate and sculpt the party’s agenda. I think it’s obviously more than ironic that we had an anti-oligarch, populist election, and the first thing that many major Democrats are doing are rushing to a conference funded by a billionaire, a billionaire-funded group. There’s an irony there. There’s a tension there. And I think the question is: What comes out of it?
AMY GOODMAN: David, we just have 30 seconds, but I want to go back to one of the top headlines this week, and that is that the Democrats, just by not showing up, not by being outvoted by the Republicans, they basically scuttled the possible impeachment of Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth. This goes to Hakeem Jeffries, who would be the majority leader, is the minority leader in the House. What happened?
DAVID SIROTA: I think it raises serious questions about how serious the Democratic leadership is, and some rank-and-file members of Congress, really the party itself. How serious are you about understanding the assignment and understanding the most basic things that need to be done to challenge Donald Trump? And I do think it is a huge question, in particular, as you allude to, for Hakeem Jeffries. Getting members to show up is the most basic, basic job of being a House leader, and certainly a House speaker.
AMY GOODMAN: David Sirota, we want to thank you for being with us, founder and editor-in-chief of The Lever. It has a new series, Don’t F#*k It Up, Democrats.
Coming up, as votes are still being counted in Alaska Senate and governor’s race, we’ll speak with Rob Richie of Expand Democracy about how ranked-choice voting could shape the Alaska election, and the growing movement to elect presidents by national popular vote rather than through the Electoral College. Back in 20 seconds.
[break]
AMY GOODMAN: “Greed” by Sweet Honey in the Rock in our firehouse studio years ago.











Media Options